Analysing Primary Sources: Foreign Travellers’ Accounts of India

Aim

To read what Xuanzang and the Arab historian Al-Masudi wrote about India, and use it to learn about society, religion and rulers in the 6th–10th centuries.

Apparatus

  • Three excerpts — Xuanzang on Kannauj and Harsha, Xuanzang on the people outside the city, Al-Masudi on a Rashtrakuta king
  • Two highlighters of different colours (yellow and pink)
  • A notebook with the observation table

Procedure

  1. Read the three excerpts carefully. Tap each one, from the left.
  2. With the yellow highlighter, mark the facts — details that could be checked.
  3. With the pink highlighter, mark the authors’ opinions or impressions.
  4. Fill the table for each source — author, date, one detail and one limitation.
  5. Discuss in pairs why Xuanzang wrote. Turn the card to see.
  6. Note why travellers’ accounts are valuable to historians despite their limits.

Interactive 3D Experiment

What to observe

  • A fact is a detail that can be checked, such as Kannauj’s ditch and towers or the coins of the Rashtrakuta kingdom.
  • An opinion is the author’s impression, such as ‘the greatest of the kings’ or a king who ‘forgot to sleep or to eat’.
  • Xuanzang saw butchers, fishers, scavengers and others made to live outside the city walls.
  • Al-Masudi praised the Rashtrakuta king because Islam was honoured and protected in his kingdom.
  • Each traveller was an outsider with his own beliefs, so historians check them against inscriptions and coins.

Notes

  • Xuanzang’s travelogue is one of the most valuable sources for 7th-century India, even though he wrote mainly to record Buddhist sites and teachings, not political history.
  • Do not treat a single source as the whole truth. Cross-check a traveller’s account with other evidence, such as inscriptions or coins.
  • The excerpts are the travellers’ own words in old public-domain translations — Samuel Beal’s Xuanzang (1884) and Elliot & Dowson’s Al-Masudi (1867).