The Token Model — Zero Pairs

Aim

Add and subtract integers with coloured tokens, and prove the idea of a 'zero pair': one positive and one negative token together have value zero.

Apparatus

  • About 40 tokens in two colours, green (positive) and red (negative). Bottle caps, buttons or paper discs work well.
  • Two small trays or circles drawn on paper to hold the tokens
  • Coloured pencils
  • Notebook and pencil

Procedure

  1. A green token is +1 and a red token is −1. A green and a red together make a zero pair worth 0.
  2. (+5) + (−3): lay 5 green and 3 red. Remove each zero pair. 2 green are left, so the answer is +2.
  3. Do (+6) + (+4), (−3) + (−2), (−2) + (+6) and (+5) + (−7), removing all zero pairs each time.
  4. (+5) − (+4): simply take away 4 green tokens and read what is left.
  5. (+5) − (+6) and +4 − (−6): add zero pairs until there are enough, then take away.
  6. Check that (−7) − (−5) gives the same result as (−7) + (+5).
  7. Record the tokens laid down, the zero pairs added or removed, and the result.

Interactive 3D Experiment

What to observe

  • Zero pairs can be added or removed freely. They never change the value.
  • (−7) − (−5) and (−7) + (+5) both give −2: subtracting a number is the same as adding its additive inverse.

Notes

  • In China's 'Nine Chapters on Mathematical Art' (about the 1st–2nd century CE), positive and negative numbers were shown with red and black counting rods.
  • In India, Kautilya wrote about credit and debit (a balance that can go negative) in the Arthashastra, around 300 BCE.
  • Fix the colours at the start (green = +1, red = −1) and keep them the same throughout.
  • Remove zero pairs only as complete green–red pairs. A single token can never be removed on its own.
  • When there are not enough tokens to take away, add zero pairs first. They do not change the value.
  • Add exactly as many zero pairs as you need.
  • Count the leftover tokens carefully and give the answer the sign of that colour.
  • Keep all the tokens inside the tray or the drawn circle so that none is lost or counted twice.