The Date Detective

Aim

Decode the ‘Think of a Date’ trick using letter-numbers, recover a hidden date from the final answer, and change the trick so that a different number has to be subtracted at the end.

Apparatus

  • A wall calendar or desk calendar of the current year
  • Slips of paper, pencils and a notebook for recording
  • Chart paper and coloured sketch pens for the flow chart
  • A calculator, only for checking the arithmetic afterwards

Procedure

  1. Write the seven steps: think of a date, month × 5, add 6, × 4, add 9, × 5, add the day.
  2. Partner A thinks of a date and keeps it secret. Partner B reads the steps. A announces only the answer.
  3. Partner B subtracts 165: the last two digits are the day, the digits before them the month.
  4. Check with Partner A. Repeat for 25/12, 07/08, 15/08 and a birthday. Fill in the table.
  5. Let the month be M and the day D. Write the expression after each step. Is it 100M + 165 + D?
  6. Explain why the day and the month never get mixed up in the final number.
  7. Change ‘add 9’ to ‘add 4’. Use algebra to find the new number to subtract. Test it.

Interactive 3D Experiment

What to observe

  • The steps give 5M, 5M + 6, 20M + 24, 20M + 33, 100M + 165 and finally 100M + 165 + D.
  • Answer − 165 = 100M + D: the last two digits are the day, the digits before them the month.
  • D is less than 100, so it never carries into the hundreds: day and month never mix.
  • With ‘add 4’ instead of ‘add 9’ the answer is 100M + 140 + D, so 140 is subtracted.

Notes

  • Math Spark: the trick rests on place value. The month is multiplied by 5 × 4 × 5 = 100, which pushes it into the hundreds place, while the day, never more than 31, stays in the tens and units. The 6 and 9 only disguise the trick: they become 6 × 4 × 5 + 9 × 5 = 120 + 45 = 165, exactly what you subtract. Calendar formulas such as Zeller’s rule use the same idea to find the weekday of any date.
  • Follow the seven instructions in the correct order and finish each one before the next.
  • Multiply the whole running total, not just the last part added.
  • Read the last two digits as the day: 7 August gives 807, so M = 8 and D = 07.
  • Take the month as its number, 1 to 12, and the day as 1 to 31.
  • Do not reveal the date until the final answer has been announced and decoded.
  • When the constant is changed, rework the algebra from the beginning; do not adjust 165 by guesswork.
  • Test any changed version on at least three dates before using it.
  • Use the calculator only to check the arithmetic after the trick is done.