The Balancing Act

Aim

Locate the mean of a collection of data on a number line using dot plots and a physical balance model, and verify that the sum of the distances of the values to the left of the mean equals the sum of the distances to its right.

Apparatus

  • Graph paper or a dot-grid notebook, ruler and pencil
  • Coloured sketch pens (at least three colours)
  • A 30 cm wooden or plastic scale and a round pencil (or a small cylinder) to act as a fulcrum
  • About 20 identical coins, washers or bottle caps to serve as equal weights
  • Small paper slips and sticky notes for writing data values

Procedure

  1. On graph paper, draw a number line from 0 to 15, marking every whole number.
  2. Mark 3 and 7 as dots. Calculate their mean, mark it with a cross, and measure the distance of each dot from it.
  3. Try other pairs of your own. Note where the mean lies with respect to the two dots.
  4. For 6, 7, 8 then 3, 6, 9 then 2, 4, 9 then 4, 6, 6, 12, mark the dots and the mean. Record the LHS and RHS sums.
  5. Rest the 30 cm scale across the round pencil like a see-saw. Its cm marks are your number line.
  6. Put one coin on each mark of 3 and 7. Slide the pencil until the scale balances and read the mark. Compare it with the mean.
  7. Repeat for 10, 10, 11 and 17, with two coins at 10. Record the balancing point.
  8. Move the pencil to a trial centre a little larger than the mean, 13, and find the LHS and RHS sums again.
  9. Why can a collection of data have only one balance point?

Interactive 3D Experiment

What to observe

  • For every collection the total distance of the values left of the mean equals the total distance of those right of it.
  • The scale balances with the pencil at the mark equal to the mean: the mean is the balance point of the data.
  • At a trial centre larger than the mean the two sums are unequal (8 and 4 for 13), so there is only one balance point. The mean always lies between the smallest and the largest value.

Notes

  • Math Spark: the mean is sometimes called the centre of gravity of the data. Physicists use the same calculation to find where a see-saw balances: a data value far from the centre behaves like a child sitting far from the pivot. The word ‘average’ comes from the Arabic ‘awariya’, used by medieval traders for goods damaged at sea; the loss was shared equally among all the merchants.
  • Use coins, washers or caps that are identical in weight; unequal weights shift the balance point.
  • Place each coin exactly on its centimetre mark, and stack coins one above the other when a value is repeated.
  • Rest the scale on a round pencil so it can tip freely, on a flat, level surface.
  • Slide the pencil slowly and let the scale settle before reading the balance point.
  • Read the balancing mark to the nearest millimetre and accept a small difference from the calculated mean as experimental error due to friction and the weight of the scale itself.
  • Mark the mean with a cross above the number line, distinct from the data dots.
  • Measure the distance of each value from the mean as a positive distance, and add the left and right sums separately.
  • Keep the number line evenly scaled — every unit must occupy the same length.