Sorting It Out — Handpicking, Sieving and Winnowing

Aim

Separate dry mixtures by handpicking, sieving and winnowing, and find the property of the parts that each method uses.

Apparatus

  • A small mixture of rice grains and tiny stones
  • A small mixture of wheat flour with bran and a few small stones
  • A handful of roasted peanuts (with loose skins)
  • A kitchen sieve
  • A flat plate, tray or stiff cardboard (to act as a winnowing tray)
  • Two empty plates or trays for the separated parts
  • Science notebook and pencil

Procedure

  1. Handpick the stones out of the rice, one by one.
  2. Note what you see about the two parts.
  3. Pass the flour, bran and stones through the sieve over a plate.
  4. Rub the roasted peanuts gently to loosen their skins.
  5. Put the peanuts and skins on the tray and toss gently in a slow breeze.
  6. Write what you saw for each mixture in the table.
  7. Compare the three methods. Which property does each one use?

Interactive 3D Experiment

What to observe

  • Which parts were picked out, which passed through the sieve and which stayed on it?
  • Which part of the peanuts was carried away by the breeze, and which stayed behind?
  • Which property (size, weight or colour) does each method use?

Safety

  • Do not eat the rice, flour or peanuts. Wash your hands with soap before and after.
  • Anyone allergic to peanuts must not handle, rub or sit near them. Tell the teacher beforehand.
  • Winnow gently from a low height, with your face turned away and classmates behind you. Never throw the mixture into the air.
  • Use a natural breeze or a slow fan, never a fast fan or blowing towards anyone's face. Students with asthma or a cold should not winnow.
  • Sieve gently over the plate without banging it on the desk, and sweep up spills at once.

Notes

  • The bamboo winnowing tray, called a soop, is shaped differently in different regions: flatter for grain, deeper for pulses, because the best shape depends on how heavy the husk is compared with the grain.