Similar or Distorted? Testing Images with Ratios

Aim

Measure the width and height of five image cards, write each width : height ratio in simplest form, and find out why images whose width and height change by the same factor look similar, while others look stretched or squashed.

Apparatus

  • One picture printed in five different sizes, labelled A to E (or the five rectangles of Fig. 1.1 cut out of card)
  • Ruler with millimetre markings (15 cm or 30 cm)
  • Graph paper or dot grid notebook
  • Coloured pencils or sketch pens (at least 3 colours)
  • Scissors, gum and a pair of set squares (optional)

Procedure

  1. Spread the cards A to E. Without measuring, sort them into 'looks like the original' and 'stretched or squashed'.
  2. Measure the width and height of every card to the nearest millimetre and fill the table.
  3. Write width : height for each card and divide both terms by their HCF to get the simplest form.
  4. Tick the cards whose simplest form is the same as A's. Do they match your guess?
  5. Find the factor of change from A: divide the width by A's width and the height by A's height. Are they equal?
  6. Try the difference method: subtract A's width and height from a card's. Does an equal difference give a similar card?
  7. On graph paper draw a 3 cm × 2 cm rectangle and a smaller and a larger one of the same ratio from one corner. Draw the diagonal.
  8. Write the test you would use to decide whether two rectangles are similar.

Interactive 3D Experiment

What to observe

  • The cards that look like A have the same simplest ratio as A, 3 : 2.
  • In a similar card the width and the height change by the same factor. An equal difference does not keep the shape.
  • Rectangles with the same ratio drawn from one corner have their far corners on one straight diagonal.

Notes

  • Math Spark: A4 paper has a ratio of about 1 : 1.414. Fold it in half and each half has the same ratio, which is why A3, A4 and A5 look alike. Screens are 4 : 3 or 16 : 9; stretching 4 : 3 video to 16 : 9 makes faces look wide and flat.
  • Sort and record your guess before measuring, so the measurements do not influence it.
  • Put the ruler's zero mark exactly at the edge of the card, and measure the card, not its printed border.
  • Always write the ratio as width : height, in the same order for every card.
  • Divide both terms by their full HCF so the ratio is in its simplest form.
  • Both quantities must be in the same unit before a ratio is written.
  • When finding the factor of change, divide the new value by A's value. Do not subtract.
  • Draw the rectangles from the same corner of the grid so the diagonal test can be applied.