Shiny or Dull, Hard or Soft? — Sorting Materials by Appearance and Hardness

Aim

Observe, group and record materials as shiny (lustrous) or dull (non-lustrous), and as hard or soft.

Apparatus

  • Science notebook / lab record and pencil
  • Small pieces of paper, cardboard, wood, chalk, stone, copper wire and aluminium foil
  • Any article made of brass, bronze or steel (for example a spoon or key)
  • A metal key or similar blunt object for the scratch test
  • Everyday objects such as a water bottle, pillow, table, tumbler and a sweater

Procedure

  1. Collect the pieces of paper, cardboard, wood, chalk, stone, copper wire and aluminium foil.
  2. Hold each piece up to the light. Is it shiny or dull?
  3. Record each result in Table 1.
  4. Gently scratch wood, aluminium, stone and chalk with the metal key.
  5. Note which materials scratch easily (soft) and which resist (hard).
  6. Hold each object in your hands. Is it hard or soft? What is it made of?
  7. Record your findings in Table 2 and compare them with a partner's.

Interactive 3D Experiment

What to observe

  • Which materials look shiny and which look dull?
  • Which materials does the key scratch easily?
  • Which objects feel hard and which feel soft?

Safety

  • Use only a blunt key for the scratch test, never a blade, knife, compass point, scissors or nail. Scratch away from your holding hand.
  • Scratch only the samples provided, never desks, walls, window panes, floors or anyone's belongings.
  • The cut ends of copper wire and aluminium foil are sharp. Hold them by the middle and ask the teacher to blunt or tape the ends.
  • Never test hardness by biting, licking or tasting, and never test an electrical wire, plug, socket or appliance.
  • Do not crush chalk into dust or blow it towards anyone. Wipe chalk dust with a damp cloth and wash your hands afterwards.

Notes

  • A material can lose its shine over time. Freshly cut iron or copper looks bright, but air and moisture make the surface dull. That is why old copper coins look brownish.