Settle, Pour, Strain — Sedimentation, Decantation and Filtration

Aim

Separate insoluble solids from water using sedimentation, decantation and filtration, and compare how well each method works.

Apparatus

  • Fine soil or mud
  • Two transparent glasses or beakers
  • A piece of clean cotton cloth
  • Filter paper and a funnel
  • A conical flask or a third glass to collect the filtrate
  • A spoon for stirring
  • Science notebook / lab record and pencil

Procedure

  1. Stir a spoonful of soil into a glass of water to make it muddy.
  2. Let the glass stand undisturbed for about ten minutes and watch the soil settle.
  3. Tilt the glass gently and pour the clearer water off the top into an empty glass.
  4. Pour a fresh muddy sample through cotton cloth stretched over a glass.
  5. Fold the filter paper into a cone, put it in the funnel over the flask and pour a fresh sample through.
  6. Compare the clarity of the water from the cloth and from the filter paper.
  7. Record what you see for each method in the observation table.

Interactive 3D Experiment

What to observe

  • What happens to the soil particles when the muddy water stands still?
  • Is the water poured off after settling completely clear?
  • Which is clearer, the water from the cloth or the water from the filter paper?
  • Why does filtration remove fine mud more completely than decantation alone?

Safety

  • Never drink or taste the filtrate. Clear-looking water is still not safe, because filtering removes mud but not germs.
  • Stir gently and pour slowly with the receiving glass held close. If muddy water splashes into an eye, wash it with plenty of clean water and tell the teacher.
  • Handle glass beakers and the funnel carefully, prefer plastic tumblers, and never pick up broken glass with bare hands.
  • Keep the glass on a stable surface while it settles, set the funnel firmly in the flask and do not overfill it.
  • Do not pour soil or residue down the sink, as it blocks the drain. Wipe up spills at once and wash your hands with soap.

Notes

  • Large city water-treatment plants use the same two ideas, just bigger. Huge settling tanks let mud sink (sedimentation), then the clearer water passes through layers of sand and gravel that work like a giant filter before it reaches our taps.