Question the Answer — Learning to Ask Like a Scientist

Aim

To practise framing curious, creative questions that could lead to a given answer, and to sort those questions into ones that can be tested by an experiment and ones that cannot.

Apparatus

  • Science notebook / lab record and pencil
  • Small slips of paper or index cards, about ten for each pair
  • A box, bowl or envelope to hold the folded slips (the class Question Box)
  • Chart paper and sketch pens for displaying the best questions
  • Two or three everyday things to wonder about (a lemon, a magnet, an ice cube in a glass, a torch)

Procedure

  1. Work in pairs. Read the answer on the card and think of questions it could be a reply to.
  2. Sort each question. Can an experiment test it, or is it only an opinion?
  3. Choose one testable question.
  4. Choose how to test it: change one thing and keep two things the same.
  5. Write the answer, the questions, the verdicts and the test in the observation table.
  6. Write your most interesting question on a slip and drop it into the Question Box.

Interactive 3D Experiment

What to observe

  • The same answer can be the reply to many different questions.
  • A testable question can be answered by doing something. An opinion cannot.
  • A fair test changes one thing and keeps two things the same.

Safety

  • Treat the objects brought for wondering (a lemon, a magnet, an ice cube, a torch) as apparatus, not toys. Do not taste the lemon or any other sample.
  • Keep the magnet away from a watch, a mobile phone or a calculator, and do not shine the torch into anybody's eyes.
  • Wipe up the water from the melting ice cube at once so that nobody slips.
  • Write no one's name on the question slips, and make no remark that could hurt a classmate whose question is read aloud.
  • Handle the scissors and sketch pens carefully, cap the pens after use, and return every slip and the Question Box to the teacher.

Notes

  • Did you know? The Nobel Prize-winning physicist I. I. Rabi said his mother made him a scientist without meaning to. Other mothers asked their children what they had learnt at school. His mother asked whether he had asked a good question that day.