Proving Patterns with Pictures

Aim

Use dot pictures to show that the sum of the first n odd numbers, starting from 1, is always a square number (n × n).

Apparatus

  • Graph paper (at least 8 × 8 grid)
  • Six different coloured sketch pens or highlighters
  • Ruler and pencil

Procedure

  1. On graph paper, mark one dot at a corner of the grid. It stands for the first odd number, 1.
  2. Around it, add an L-shaped border of 3 dots in a second colour. Count the total — it is 4.
  3. Add L-shaped borders of 5, 7, 9 and 11 dots, each in a new colour, and record each running total.
  4. Check that each running total is a square number, then use the pattern for the row n = 10.
  5. Draw the 'adding up and down' diamonds 1, 1 + 2 + 1, 1 + 2 + 3 + 2 + 1, … and check each total.

Interactive 3D Experiment

What to observe

  • What does each new border add?
  • Are all the totals square numbers?
  • Discuss: why does it work for a grid of any size?

Notes

  • The ancient Greeks called 1, 4, 9 and 16 'square numbers' because they arranged pebbles in square shapes on the ground, more than 2500 years ago.
  • They called the L-shaped strip added to a square a 'gnomon', because it looked like the shape of a sundial seen from above.
  • Work on graph paper so that every dot sits where two grid lines cross and the L-shape stays exact.
  • Begin at a corner of the grid, so there is room for the borders to grow outwards.
  • Each border must wrap around two sides of the square so far — do not add the dots in a straight line.
  • Use a fresh colour for each border, and count that border before adding the next one.
  • Check every running total against its square number before moving on.
  • Keep the dots of each diamond symmetrical about its middle row.