Diagnosing the Problems of Barter

Aim

To name the problems of the barter system shown in a set of scenarios, and to explain how money solves each one. The problems are double coincidence of wants, no common standard of value, divisibility, portability and durability.

Apparatus

  • Textbook reference (the farmer's story)
  • A notebook
  • Coloured pencils or sticky notes

Procedure

  1. Revisit the five problems of barter described in the chapter.
  2. Draw a table with two columns, Scenario and Problem of Barter Illustrated.
  3. Read the eight scenarios. Decide which of the five problems each one shows.
  4. For each scenario, write one line on how using money instead of goods would solve it.
  5. Swap answers with a partner and talk about any scenario you disagreed on.
  6. Answer the reflection question about which problem would trouble traders most on longer routes.

Interactive 3D Experiment

What to observe

  • Two scenarios each show double coincidence of wants, no common standard of value, and durability.
  • Divisibility and portability are each shown once.
  • Money, as a common medium of exchange, solves each of the five problems.

Notes

  • Social Science Spark: the barter system never fully disappeared. The Junbeel Mela in Assam, held every year since the 15th century, is a fair where communities still exchange local produce and handmade goods without money.
  • Match each scenario to only one problem. Use the chapter's definitions when in doubt.