Comparing Monarchy and Gana-Sangha Systems of Governance

Aim

To compare the monarchical and gana-sangha (republican) systems of governance among the mahajanapadas, using a chart and a sabhā meeting.

Apparatus

  • Chart paper, sketch pens or markers and a ruler
  • Slips of paper for voting

Procedure

  1. In small groups, draw a two-column chart headed Monarchy and Gana-Sangha.
  2. List at least four features under each column: how the ruler was chosen, who decided, examples.
  3. Role-play a sabhā meeting of a gana-sangha such as Vajji. Discuss a simple issue, for example a new well, and decide by vote.
  4. Watch the discussion and note how decisions were reached differently from a monarchy.
  5. Record your comparison in the observation table.

Interactive 3D Experiment

What to observe

  • In a monarchy the king took the major decisions.
  • In a gana-sangha the assembly took them, after discussion and a vote.
  • Vajji and Malla were gana-sanghas; Magadha and Avanti were monarchies.

Notes

  • Social Science Spark: the words sabhā and samiti first appear in the Vedas. In a gana-sangha the assembly members, usually clan elders, held real power, including the power to remove an incompetent ruler.
  • Keep the role-play respectful and orderly. Give every group member a chance to speak before the vote.