Mixture or Compound? — Investigating Iron Filings and Sulfur
Aim
Make a mixture of iron filings and sulfur, turn part of it into a compound by heating, and compare the properties of the mixture and the compound.
Apparatus
- Iron filings and sulfur powder
- A watch glass, a china dish and a bar magnet
- Test tubes, a test-tube stand and a test-tube holder
- A mortar and pestle
- A tripod stand, wire gauze and a burner (or spirit lamp)
- Dilute hydrochloric acid and a magnifying glass
- Safety goggles, a glass rod and a wooden splinter
- Science notebook and pencil
Procedure
- Mix about 5.6 g of iron filings and 3.2 g of sulfur powder on a watch glass. This is Sample A.
- Look at Sample A with a magnifying glass. Can you see the iron and the sulfur separately?
- Heat half of Sample A gently in a china dish on wire gauze, stirring, until a black mass forms.
- Let the dish cool. Grind the black mass in a mortar with a pestle. This is Sample B.
- Magnet test: move a bar magnet over Sample A, then over Sample B.
- Gas test: add dilute hydrochloric acid to each sample. Waft the gas, then bring a burning splinter.
- Record all your observations in the table.

Interactive 3D Experiment
Loading simulation…
What to observe
- Can you still see the black iron and the yellow sulfur in Sample A? And in Sample B?
- Does the magnet pull anything out of Sample A? Out of Sample B?
- How does the gas from each sample smell, and does it burn with a pop?
- Which sample is a mixture, and which is a new substance (a compound)?
Safety
- Heat and do the acid tests only under your teacher's supervision, in a well-ventilated room or a fume hood.
- Wear safety goggles while heating, tie back long hair and keep loose clothing away from the flame.
- Heat the china dish gently and stir all the time — strong or uneven heating makes the mixture spit.
- Let the dish cool completely before touching it or grinding its contents. Hot and cold dishes look alike.
- Handle dilute hydrochloric acid with great care. If it touches skin, eyes or clothes, wash at once with plenty of water.
- Never smell a gas directly. Waft a little towards your nose with your hand.
- Point the mouth of the test tube away from yourself and others.
- Wipe the magnet clean before and after each test; cover it with a paper or plastic sheet.
- Get rid of the leftovers as your teacher says, and wash your hands well afterwards.
Notes
- A magnet cannot pick up iron once it has combined with sulfur. In iron sulfide the iron is locked into a new compound and loses its magnetic pull — proof that a compound is a new substance, not just a blend of two elements.
- Word equation: Iron + Sulfur → (on heating) → Iron sulfide.