Is Sugar an Element? — Decomposing Sugar by Heating

Aim

To show, by heating, that sugar is a compound which can be broken down into simpler substances — carbon and water.

Apparatus

  • Sugar (about a teaspoonful)
  • Boiling tube and test-tube holder
  • Spirit lamp (or burner)
  • Watch glass
  • Science notebook and pencil

Procedure

  1. Put a teaspoon of sugar into a dry boiling tube.
  2. Hold the tube with a test-tube holder and heat it gently, its mouth pointed away from everyone.
  3. Watch the colour of the sugar. Note when it turns brown and then blackish.
  4. Look at the cooler upper part of the tube, near its mouth. Record what collects there.
  5. Heat until nothing more changes. Let the tube cool, then scoop the black solid onto a watch glass.
  6. Record all your observations in the table.

Interactive 3D Experiment

What to observe

  • The white sugar first melts, then turns brown and finally leaves a black, porous, spongy solid. This is carbon.
  • Colourless droplets of water collect on the cool upper wall of the tube, near its mouth.
  • The tube was dry at the start, so the water came from the sugar itself.
  • One substance broke down into two simpler ones, so sugar is not an element. It is a compound of carbon, hydrogen and oxygen.
  • Word equation: Sugar → (on heating) → Carbon + Water

Safety

  • Do this activity only in the presence of a teacher.
  • The boiling tube must be completely dry before the sugar goes in.
  • Take only about a teaspoonful of sugar. Never fill the tube more than about a quarter.
  • Hold the tube with a test-tube holder, never with bare fingers or a cloth.
  • Keep the mouth of the tube pointed away from yourself and everyone else.
  • Heat gently and keep moving the tube through the flame. Strong heating in one place cracks the glass and makes the sugar spurt.
  • Molten sugar is very hot and sticky. Never touch it or smell the tube closely.
  • Let the tube cool fully on a stand before you examine the black solid. Never put a hot tube on a cold surface or into water.
  • Tie back long hair, keep the flame away from books and clothes, and put the lamp out with its cap, never by blowing.

Notes

  • Science Spark: The black solid left when sugar is heated is almost pure carbon, the same element found in charcoal, pencil graphite and diamond. Sugar is C₁₂H₂₂O₁₁: twelve carbons, with hydrogen and oxygen in the 2 : 1 ratio found in water.