Cracking ‘Think of a Number’ Tricks

Aim

Perform, generalise and justify ‘Think of a Number’ tricks by replacing the secret number with a letter-number, and design a new trick whose final answer is fixed in advance.

Apparatus

  • Slips of paper and pencils (one set per pair)
  • A pack of digit cards 0 to 9, or two dice, to generate starting numbers
  • Chart paper and coloured sketch pens (at least 3 colours)
  • A calculator, only for checking large starting numbers

Procedure

  1. Work in pairs. Partner A reads: think of a number, double it, add 4, divide by 2, subtract the number. Partner B works silently.
  2. Partner A announces the answer before Partner B speaks. Swap roles and repeat.
  3. Try at least five starting numbers, including a two-digit number, a three-digit number, 0 and 1/2. Record every stage.
  4. Let the secret number be the letter-number x. Write the expression after each step, one below the other.
  5. Simplify the last expression. Why does the starting number disappear?
  6. Change exactly one instruction, for example ‘Add 4’ to ‘Add 10’. Predict the new answer with algebra, then test it.
  7. Design your own trick of at least six steps whose answer is always 5. Try it on three classmates.

Interactive 3D Experiment

What to observe

  • Whatever starting number is chosen, the final answer is the same: 2.
  • With x for the secret number, (2x + 4) ÷ 2 − x = x + 2 − x = 2: the terms in x cancel and only a constant is left.
  • Changing ‘Add 4’ to ‘Add k’ makes the fixed answer k ÷ 2. Working backwards from a chosen answer designs a new trick.

Notes

  • Math Spark: the word ‘algebra’ comes from al-jabr, part of the title of a book by Al-Khwarizmi in Baghdad around 820 CE; ‘algorithm’ comes from his name too. In 628 CE Brahmagupta used abbreviations of colour names (yavat tavat, kalaka, nilaka) as symbols for unknown quantities, much as we use x, y and z. Every ‘Think of a Number’ trick is an algebraic identity wearing a costume: write x instead of a number and the costume falls off.
  • Carry out the instructions in the given order; changing the order changes the expression.
  • Use the same letter for the secret number at every step, and write the expression after each instruction before moving on.
  • Use brackets when a whole expression is doubled or halved: 2x + 8 halved is x + 4, not 2x + 4.
  • Simplify fully and check that the term in the letter really cancels before claiming the answer is fixed.
  • Test the trick with at least three different starting numbers, including 0 and a large number.
  • When designing a new trick, work backwards from the fixed answer and then verify the algebra forwards.
  • Keep the starting number secret from the partner until the trick is complete.
  • Use the calculator only to check the arithmetic for large starting numbers.