Counting Without Modern Numbers

Aim

Represent and compare quantities the way early people did, with one-to-one mapping and tally marks. Group the tallies in fives, and write the same numbers in the Roman number system.

Apparatus

  • A handful of sticks, matchsticks, pebbles or bottle caps (about 30)
  • A set of small objects to count (buttons, beads or beans)
  • Dot grid or plain paper notebook
  • Coloured pencils or sketch pens (at least 3 colours)
  • Ruler and pencil

Procedure

  1. Put one stick beside each object. This is a one-to-one mapping, so no object shares a stick.
  2. Match the two stick-piles stick for stick to see which collection is larger, and by how many.
  3. Record numbers as tally marks, one vertical mark for each object.
  4. At five marks, cross the four with a diagonal "gate" line and bundle in fives, up to 20.
  5. Write each number in Roman numerals using I, V, X, L, C and D. Remember 4 is IV and 9 is IX.
  6. For every number, write in your own words the rule you used to go from tallies to the Roman numeral.

Interactive 3D Experiment

What to observe

  • Matching sticks one to one shows which collection is larger, and by how many, without any number name.
  • Tallies bundled in fives are far quicker to read than a long unbroken row of strokes.
  • In Roman numerals 4 is IV and 9 is IX, and no symbol is written more than three times in a row.
  • Grouping is what turns a record of counting into a usable number system.

Notes

  • Math Spark: the Lebombo bone, found in South Africa, is a tally stick with 29 notches, about 44 000 years old. The Roman system has no zero, which makes adding and multiplying large numbers awkward, so merchants used a counting board, the abacus.
  • Place exactly one stick against one object. A stick shared between two objects breaks the mapping.
  • Keep the two collections and their stick-piles separate so they do not get mixed.
  • Compare the piles by matching them stick for stick. Do not count them in number names.
  • Draw four upright marks and cross the fifth diagonally across them. Do not draw five upright marks and then a line beside them.
  • Do not write the same Roman symbol more than three times in a row. Write IV and IX, not IIII and VIIII.
  • Check that each tally record and its Roman numeral stand for the same count before writing the rule.