Classifying Disputes and Choosing the Appropriate Forum

Aim

To sort everyday disputes by the forum best suited to them - a regular court, a specialised tribunal or an alternate dispute resolution (ADR) mechanism - and to understand how they differ.

Apparatus

  • Chart paper or a notebook
  • Pencil
  • Dispute-scenario cards
  • The textbook's sections on Tribunals and Alternate Modes of Dispute Resolution
  • The textbook's Fig. 4.7

Procedure

  1. Take at least eight dispute cards from daily life.
  2. For each, decide the forum - a court, a tribunal (name it) or an ADR mechanism.
  3. Make a two-column chart - 'Forum/Mechanism' and 'Type of Dispute It Handles'.
  4. Role-play one dispute as a mediation session - two parties and one mediator.
  5. Record your classification for all scenarios in the observation table.
  6. Discuss why some disputes are better settled through ADR than in a court case.

Interactive 3D Experiment

What to observe

  • Regular courts hear cases that need proof and a judge's decision, and appeals.
  • Tribunals deal with one subject, like the environment or government service.
  • ADR (mediation, Lok Adalat, arbitration) is quicker and cheaper, and the parties agree.

Notes

  • Keep the role-play respectful; do not target real people.
  • Use the correct legal terms from the textbook.