Balancing the Unknown

Aim

To find unknown weights using a simple balance, and to discover the key principle behind solving equations: if we do the same thing to both sides of a balanced scale, it stays balanced. Set the balance so the two empty pans rest level. This level position is your equal sign (=).

Apparatus

  • A simple balance (a 30 cm ruler pivoted on a pencil, or a coat-hanger with two identical cups)
  • About 20 identical unit weights (coins, metal washers, or marbles of the same kind)
  • 3–4 small paper bags or envelopes to hide unknown weights
  • Sticky labels and a pencil

Procedure

  1. Put the sealed bag on the right pan. Add unit weights on the left until the pans balance. Open the bag to check.
  2. Bag + 2 units on the left, 6 units on the right. Take 2 from BOTH pans. Write w + 2 = 6.
  3. Bag + bag against 10 units. Halve BOTH pans to find one bag. Check it. Write 2w = 10.
  4. 3 bags + 1 unit against 13 units. Take 1 from BOTH pans, then a third of BOTH. Write 3b + 1 = 13.
  5. Bag + 5 units against 5 + 5 units. Take 5 from BOTH pans. Write w + 5 = 10.
  6. In your own words, write the rule that kept the scale balanced.

Interactive 3D Experiment

What to observe

  • The pans stay level when the same thing is done to both of them.
  • Once one bag is left alone on a pan, the units on the other pan are its weight.
  • Opening the bag shows the same number of units, so the equation was solved correctly.

Notes

  • Math Spark: around 825 CE the mathematician Al-Khwarizmi wrote a book with the words al-jabr wal-muqabala, 'restoring and balancing'. Al-jabr is where our word algebra comes from. In India, Brahmagupta (628 CE) explained how to add, subtract and multiply unknown numbers using letters.
  • Check that the balance rests level with both pans empty before beginning.
  • Use unit weights that are truly identical, such as coins of the same denomination.
  • Place the weights gently and at the same distance from the pivot on both sides.
  • Always do exactly the same thing to both pans. Adding to or removing from only one destroys the balance.
  • Keep the balance on a firm, level surface away from draughts, and wait for the pans to settle before reading.
  • Label each hidden bag so its recorded weight can be checked at the end.