Analysing Primary Sources on Culture and Society

Aim

To read excerpts from historical chronicles and travellers' accounts, and to classify statements within them as fact, opinion or inference.

Apparatus

  • The four primary-source excerpts (A to D)
  • Notebook
  • Pen

Procedure

  1. Read each of the four source excerpts carefully. Note who the author was and when they wrote.
  2. For each excerpt, find one fact, one opinion and one inference.
  3. Record your answers in the observation table.
  4. Discuss in pairs: does the author's background affect how reliable or biased the account is?
  5. Share your findings with the class and compare interpretations.

Interactive 3D Experiment

What to observe

  • A fact can be checked in other sources, like the women who kept the palace accounts at Vijayanagara.
  • Words like "surpass our conceptions" and "well versed" show the author's own judgement.
  • An inference is not written in the source; the reader concludes it from what is written.
  • A court historian, a foreign visitor and a poet each write from their own point of view.

Notes

  • Social Science Spark: a fact can be checked by other sources; an opinion is a personal judgement; an inference is a reasonable conclusion from evidence. Good historians tell these apart.
  • Precautions: read each excerpt more than once; one sentence may hold more than one type of statement; do not assume a source is wholly reliable or wholly biased.
  • The excerpts are from old public-domain English translations: Abu Zaid, in Elliot and Dowson, History of India, vol. I (1867); Abul Fazl, Ain-i-Akbari, tr. H. Blochmann (1873); Fernão Nunes, tr. R. Sewell, A Forgotten Empire (1900); Kabir, Songs of Kabir, tr. R. Tagore (1915).